CLARENDON HILLS, IL – Clarendon Hills firefighters violated their department’s callback compensation policy more than 1,500 times over three years, an investigation found.
Also, the inquiry identified tensions between two groups of the department’s members.
On Tuesday, the village released an attorney’s report of a months-long investigation into the compensation system. The problems are believed to have led to the ouster of longtime Fire Chief Brian Leahy earlier this year.
Find out what's happening in Hinsdale-Clarendon Hillswith free, real-time updates from Patch.
Attorney Charles Hervas said the 1,592 violations ended up costing the village $52,000 from 2020 to 2023.
On Jan. 1, 2020, Leahy started staffing the fire department with four personnel at all times, rather than three. The stated intent was to reduce the callbacks of paid-on-call firefighters related to minor alarms and mutual aid calls to Hinsdale lasting less than 15 minutes, which was later extended to Westmont.
Find out what's happening in Hinsdale-Clarendon Hillswith free, real-time updates from Patch.
In 2020, callback violations made up 8 percent of all calls, which increased to 12 percent in 2021 and 15 percent in 2022. The rate dropped to 10 percent in the first nine months of 2023.
A couple of months ago, Leahy, who was put on leave in November, entered a severance agreement with the village. As part of the pact, he agreed to be interviewed for Hervas’ investigation. The interview was March 5.
In his report, Hervas said the tension between part-time firefighter paramedics and paid-on-call firefighters was an issue in every interview during his investigation – a problem he recommended addressing.
Hervas’ report stated Leahy acknowledged the tension, but the chief viewed the paramedics as the main complainers. He said the paramedics complained that paid-on-call members abused the callback system, the report said.
Leahy was described as shocked that the investigation identified more than 1,000 violations. Leahy said it was impossible to have that high of a number, according to the report.
“As far as the Chief was concerned, so long as the monthly numbers were in line with the budget, he believed the callback situation was not a problem,” Hervas wrote.
In an interview late last year, administrative Lt. Jim Weil, who was also put on leave in November, acknowledged the callback policy was not properly followed over the three years. But he said it was not abused.
Weil said he would question the accuracy of certain callbacks and bring them to Leahy’s attention, according to the report. Weil said the chief would make the final call on whether they were approved or denied.
When Leahy and Weil were put on leave, the village immediately changed the policy on callbacks.
In a memo to the Village Board on Tuesday, Village Manager Zach Creer said the village put internal controls in place for callbacks in November.
He said the village installed a new door system to track attendance, put in place new attendance sheets, and corrected past practices of “rounding up” and pyramiding hours.
Also, the village installed cameras at all of its buildings, Creer said. And employees received extended training on proper payroll procedures, he said.
Under state law, the village could have kept the lawyer’s report secret, citing the secrecy of attorney-client communications. But the village resolved some time ago to release it. It was posted on the village’s website.
The 68-year-old Leahy started as chief in 1985 and joined the department in 1971.
Click Here: Italy Rugby Shop
He couldn’t be reached for comment Tuesday.
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.